An Illegal Player And A Sham Tournament: Scandal Rocks The Little League World Series

The road to the Little League World Series is supposed to be a celebration of youth baseball. Instead, one state’s path to Williamsport this year has descended into a scandal involving an ineligible player, disputed tournament administration, improper fees, missing eligibility paperwork, and demands for the removal of state and regional Little League officials.

Read more Inside The RNC’s Biggest Convention In A Decade

The controversy centers on Tulsa National Little League, which was disqualified from the Southwest Region Tournament on Monday while representing Oklahoma after Little League International determined that one of its players was ineligible. A Texas judge briefly allowed the team to continue competing before vacating the order Tuesday, clearing the way for the tournament to proceed without the team from Oklahoma.

According to documents obtained by Sports Illustrated, Tulsa National’s eligibility problems were not confined to one player or the Southwest Region Tournament. The evidence suggests that Oklahoma’s entire state tournament may have been improperly administered, with two of the three participating teams allegedly ineligible to compete for the state’s berth in the international tournament.

Tulsa National defeated Washington County and Oklahoma City Parks & Recreation to win the Oklahoma state tournament and advance to Waco, Texas.

But Washington County had never registered players in the Little League Major Division, according to Little League data reviewed by Sports Illustrated. The league says it followed instructions from Oklahoma District Administrator Mindy Abbott and was told its team had been properly registered.

The documentation submitted by Tulsa National also contained basic procedural problems. The required Tournament Team Eligibility Affidavit was not signed by the Tulsa National Player Agent or manager Cole Abbott, while Mindy Abbott’s signature was not dated.

The more serious issue involved the player whose eligibility ultimately triggered the regional disqualification. Little League’s rules allow a player who lives outside a league’s geographic boundaries to establish eligibility through a sibling who is age seven or younger and participates in the league’s program. Court documents show that Tulsa National relied on that provision to establish the eligibility of a player identified as O.G.

But according to Little League officials, O.G.’s father had registered his younger daughter as being 7 years old when she was actually 10. Officials also determined that the girl never participated in Tulsa National’s program.

Dan Velte, Little League’s vice president of operations and international tournament director, said in court documents that the age misrepresentation rendered the sibling ineligible under the under-8 open enrollment provision and therefore made O.G. ineligible as well.

“O.G. participated in the Oklahoma State Tournament, which is part of the Little League International Tournament, while ineligible,” Velte wrote. “Under this rule, disqualification was mandatory.”

That meant the problem extended backward. Tulsa National had not merely brought an ineligible player to Waco. The player had already participated in the Oklahoma state tournament that sent the team there.

Little League International ultimately declared Tulsa National’s previous regional game a forfeit and removed the team from the Southwest Region Tournament. The decision came after three protests. Little League said the formal investigation determined that O.G. was ineligible, while court filings indicate that Tulsa National representatives initially attributed the player’s absence from the regional roster to a “falling out” between his family and the coaching staff rather than disclosing the underlying eligibility issue.

Read more CBS News Star Matt Gutman Accused Of Sexual Harassment In New Lawsuit

The parents of Tulsa National’s players subsequently blamed the adults responsible for administering the tournament.

“To our own Oklahoma administration, the Southwest Regional administration, and Little League International: this one is on you,” the parents said in a statement.

But now, the controversy has grown beyond Tulsa National. New evidence also indicates that the Oklahoma state tournament involved fees that appear to violate Little League regulations. Oklahoma District Administrator Mindy Abbott instructed the three participating teams to pay a $100 tournament entry fee. When the teams arrived, they were directed to pay the money to Tulsa Area Youth Softball and Baseball, Inc., an entity associated with the Tulsa Little League organization.

There was also a $5 gate fee charged, despite Little League rules prohibiting mandatory admission fees for Major Division games. Little League permits voluntary donations but states that “no admission shall be charged” for Major Division games. The $100 entry fee was also separate from the $300 tournament fee paid to Little League International for eligible teams in certain divisions.

The organizational structure surrounding the tournament has only added to the confusion. Tulsa Area Youth Softball and Baseball, Inc., Tulsa Little League, Inc., Tulsa Little League Baseball, Inc., and Tulsa National Little League are separate entities, but they are all controlled or operated by Tulsa National President Stephen Skocik. Little League regulations prohibit local leagues from extending the Little League name and emblem to other organizations for unrelated purposes.

Now, more than 300 Oklahoma and Southwest Region Little League coaches, volunteers and parents are calling for the removal of Mindy Abbott and Southwest Region Director Blaine Whitmire, as well as the revocation of Tulsa National’s charter.

“We have no confidence in Oklahoma District Administrator Mindy Abbott to administer Little League in this state with the integrity, consistency and fairness its families deserve,” the group said.

The letter also called for the vacating of Tulsa National’s 2025 and 2026 Oklahoma state and Southwest Region tournament titles. “The damage caused cannot be undone,” the statement said. “But Little League International can decide whether the failures that caused it will have consequences.”

Abbott has pushed back, telling the Oklahoman that the two leagues calling for her removal “are not in compliance with Little League regulations.” Whitmire has not publicly responded to the newspaper’s request for comment.

For the children involved, the consequences are obvious. The Tulsa players lost their opportunity to compete for a place in Williamsport despite advancing through the tournament on the field. Little League International says its tournament system depends on parents and volunteers adhering to its rules and ensuring a “fair and equitable experience” for every child.

Read more Flock Announces New Privacy Protocols After Populist Backlash Against Cameras